Free Consultation
216-373-0539
Wooden judge's gavel resting on a sound block next to a large red law book on a polished wooden desk.
02/13/2024

Dannlaw Pua Update: Lawsuit is Still Pending Before Judge Holbrook, Important Alert About State Attempts to Collect “Overpayments”

Share to Social

I appreciate everyone’s patience with the slow progress of our case seeking payment of the Pandemic Unemployment Supplemental Benefits that were denied to Ohioans by Governor DeWine and the Ohio Department of Jobs and Family Services.  As an FYI, I emailed Judge Holbrook’s law clerk today and asked if there was anything we or opposing counsel needed to do to enable the judge to rule on the motion to amend our complaint that we filed on behalf of the plaintiffs in March of 2023 and/or the motion to dismiss the complaint that was filed by the State AG at about the same time.

That means our position is, unfortunately, no different now than it was when the motions were filed last spring.

As of this writing, she has yet to respond.

When/if she responds or when/if the judge rules on the pending motions we will share that information with all of you immediately.

There is another issue that I wanted to bring to your attention. Recently the Ohio Attorney General and the Department of Jobs and Family Services have begun to attempt to collect what they perceive to be overpayments to pandemic unemployment recipients. If you have received such a notice please make sure you note that there is a short period of time to appeal this finding.  Our expectation is that many of the repayment notices are inaccurate.

If you’ve received one of these notices in error and are willing to speak out about your situation please email me at md***@*****aw.com and I will connect you with folks at Policy Matters.

Here is the Alert that we recently shared on our Facebook Page from Policy Matters Ohio:

ALERT:

Ohio has begun retroactively denying unemployment benefits to some Ohioans who received them during the COVID-19 pandemic and demanding repayment.
Did you get Pandemic Unemployment Assistance (PUA)? The Ohio Department of Job and Family Services (ODJFS) recently began sending email alerts to some recipients telling them to check their PUA account for new notices. These notices may say you fraudulently received PUA and have to repay those benefits—including interest and late penalties—because you didn’t provide required identity documents. If you received PUA during the pandemic:

1. Check your email and PUA accounts immediately. ODJFS will send the alert to the email address you used when you applied for Unemployment Assistance. To log into your PUA account, visit:
https://pua.unemployment.ohio.gov/Claimant/Core/Login.ASPX

2. If you did get a notice, file an appeal by the deadline and include a copy of the required identity documents. For what documents are required, see: https://jfs.ohio.gov/…/identityverificationchecklist


3. File your appeal online at https://puaa.jfs.ohio.gov OR call 877-574-0015 to provide the needed information. Call volume is often high, so we recommend filing online if possible. You can visit your local Ohio Means Jobs office if you need to access a computer.

4. If you miss the deadline, don’t panic! You can still file an appeal, but you may need to prove you had good cause for missing the deadline.

5. Once you file your appeal, watch for new notices in your PUA account and check your mail for a Scheduling Notice with a hearing date.

6. You have the right to be represented on an appeal and should arrange representation as soon as possible. If you cannot afford a private attorney, your local legal aid society or legal services program may be able to provide help at no cost. Contact your local legal aid office at 1-866-LAW-OHIO (1-866-529-6446) or visit https://www.ohiolegalhelp.org to search the legal aid directory.

7. If you didn’t get a notice, be sure to check your email frequently and log into your PUA account to read any new notices.

Marc

Feel free to reach out and speak with our experienced team of professionals who are here to provide you with guidance.
KNOW YOUR RIGHTS.
KNOW YOUR OPTIONS.
© 2026 DANNLAW. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED
The information on this website is for general information purposes only. Nothing on this site should be taken as advice for any individual case or situation. This information is not intended to create, and receipt or viewing does not constitute a client relationship.